Sunday, May 5, 2013

Are we any different?


I just read the book ‘The Help’ by Kathryn Stockett .About Mississippi in 1962. ‘A vanished world, where black maids raise white children but aren’t trusted not to steal the silver’.

India in 2011, and we aren’t very different. We may not use the words ‘black’ and ‘white’, but the boundaries are clear as ever. The ‘them’ and the ‘us’.

The book revolves around the lives of three women, Skeeter, one of the three main protagonists, a young educated white woman , decides to venture on an untrodden path and write a book about coloured domestics in Mississipi, helped by Ailbileen and Minny, two maids working for their unreasonable and eccentric white employers. The book is very real, with the story being richly described by the three protagonists in turn, three points of view, and the reader being transported into each of their contrasting worlds with each narrative.

The incident that led to Skeeter and Aibileen take on this daring task is something that happens everywhere today- Aibileen’s employer decides to come up with an initiative where separate toilets are installed in garages of homes for the coloured folk, as they carry diseases that are fatal to white people if there was sharing of toilets. In how many of our homes today do maids get to use our bathrooms ?  We may not treat them as untouchable any more, but the lines are very much there.

Do our maids ever sit on our furniture? Eat at our tables? Use the same dishes and glasses we use? We may talk to them as almost equals, leave aside food for them, give them not-so-old clothes, pay their children’s’ school fees, but yet will they ever presume to helping themselves to a glass of water with the very cups that they wash ?

If a maid dresses well, she is considered conceited. If a maid tries to stand up for her rights by forming associations and demanding minimum wages, she is considered a trouble-maker. If she spends a little extra money in sending her children to an English-medium school, she is considered something of a squanderer.
They work seven days a week. They do not get sick leaves and pensions, almost like the house-elves in Harry Potter. They do not presume to ever look at an employer as an equal. 

Like the coloured domestics of 1962, they raise the children of working mothers. Who make sure their jewellery is safely locked up before leaving them with their toddlers . The children call the maid by their names. Why ? Would they ever call a mother’s friend by name ? But the rules of respect do not apply to fifty year old domestic helps.  

Yes, maybe some of them steal. Some of them may lie, some may be immoral. But as quoted by Atticus Finch in 'To Kill a Mockinbird', this is true of all human beings. Not to the labour class alone.
Decades have passed since civil wars and fight for human rights. But most maids in India have the same story to tell.

 Husbands who beat them up in an inebriated state. Small incomes that barely get them the necessities of life. Desperately putting children through school so that they don’t suffer like their mothers. Coming to work even when sick because otherwise the employer cuts their salary. Small makeshift houses that leak during the rain. No proper water supply and electricity. Living in squalor.
We may boast about women power, about having a woman president before the mighty USA.( A president whose voice we rarely hear, but that's a different matter.) That we have  famous women reporters and writers and entrepreneurs.  But has this in any way changed our attitude towards our maids ? When will we change ?